
Omni William Penn Hotel
Best for downtown convenience, historic character, formal dining and large events.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Omni William Penn Hotel is a landmark 4-star downtown Pittsburgh hotel (opened 1916) with classic dining, large meeting spaces and historic public rooms; read this if you want a central, formal stay for sightseeing, meetings or events. Hyatt House Pittsburgh/Bloomfield/Shadyside is a 3-star extended-stay Hyatt in the East End with suite-style rooms and free breakfast; read this if you want apartment-style space near Carnegie Mellon, UPMC Shadyside and the Shadyside/Bloomfield neighborhoods.
Updated

Best for downtown convenience, historic character, formal dining and large events.

Best for longer stays or neighborhood-focused trips needing kitchenettes, free breakfast and easy access to CMU/University of Pittsburgh.
When Omni William Penn Hotel wins: choose the Omni if you want a central downtown address within easy walking distance of PPG Paints Arena, Market Square and the convention center, if historic public rooms and multiple distinct bars/restaurants matter, or if you need large meeting/wedding venues.
When Hyatt House Pittsburgh/Bloomfield/Shadyside wins: choose the Hyatt House for suite-style rooms with kitchens/microwaves, a complimentary breakfast, an indoor pool and a 24-hour fitness center — a simpler, more practical pick for extended stays or neighborhood visits to Shadyside/Bloomfield and nearby campuses.
Bottom line: pick the Omni for atmosphere, dining variety and event capacity in downtown Pittsburgh; pick the Hyatt House for space, free breakfast and a more residential, East End location at a lower star level.
| Category | Omni William Penn Hotel | Hyatt House Pittsburgh/Bloomfield/Shadyside |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Formal, historic, downtown landmark with classic public rooms and multiple distinct bars/restaurants. | Practical, suite-style Hyatt extended-stay hotel geared to longer stays and neighborhood access. |
| Location | Downtown Pittsburgh across from Mellon Square; walkable to convention center, PPG Paints Arena and Market Square. | Bloomfield/Shadyside (East End); close to Carnegie Mellon University, University of Pittsburgh and UPMC Shadyside. |
| Size (rooms) | 597 guest rooms and 38 suites. | 128 rooms. |
| Star rating / guest rating | 4-star (AAA Four Diamond). | 3-star, guest rating listed 9/10. |
| Pools / signature amenity | No on-site swimming pool; 24-hour complimentary fitness center and in-room massage service available. | Indoor pool and 24-hour fitness center (both listed in supplier facts). |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple outlets including Terrace Room (full-service), Palm Court, The Tap Room, Speakeasy, Mellon Square Coffee and a bagel shop. | H Bar (on-site), plus a snack bar/deli and a bar/lounge; complimentary buffet breakfast included. |
| Spa | The Nail Galleria (3,500 sq ft salon/spa on lower lobby level; third-party operator). | Not published |
| Business & meeting space | Over 52,000 sq ft across 38 meeting rooms and multiple ballrooms (Grand Ballroom, William Penn Ballroom, Urban Room, etc.). | Ballroom and 1 meeting room listed; 24-hour business center available. |
| Parking & access | Valet parking (overnight) and nearby self-parking in Mellon Square garage (both charged); adjacent to Steel Plaza T station. | Self parking (surcharge) available onsite; no accessible shuttle. |
| Pets & age policy | Pet friendly (dogs/cats under 25 lbs) with $125 one-time fee; guests must be 21+ to rent a room. | Pets allowed with deposit/fees (pet deposit $200, fee $75 per pet, per stay); check-in minimum age 21. |
Omni William Penn sits in downtown Pittsburgh at 530 William Penn Place, steps from Mellon Square and within walking distance of major downtown attractions.
Choose Omni for maximum downtown walkability and easy access to major city venues.
Hyatt House is in the Bloomfield/Shadyside East End neighborhood at 5335 Baum Blvd, convenient for campuses and medical centers.
Choose Hyatt House to stay in a residential East End neighborhood near universities and medical centers.
Omni rooms are traditional hotel rooms and suites with historic detailing and multiple room categories.
Pick the Omni if you prioritize historic public spaces and traditional hotel services over kitchenette-style rooms.
Hyatt House focuses on suite-style rooms with kitchenettes and separate sitting areas for longer stays.
Pick Hyatt House when you need space, kitchenette facilities and living areas for extended or self-catered stays.
Omni offers several distinct dining outlets, from formal to casual to a historic dining room.
Choose Omni for more variety and atmospherically different dining options on-site.
Hyatt House provides simpler on-site dining suitable for longer-stay guests.
Choose Hyatt House for included breakfast and casual, convenient on-site dining.
Omni does not have an on-site swimming pool but offers a 24-hour fitness center and spa services.
Choose Omni if a pool is not a priority and you value a fitness center plus an on-site salon and historic ambiance.
Hyatt House lists an indoor pool and a 24-hour fitness center among its recreation offerings.
Choose Hyatt House if having an indoor pool and extended-stay amenities matters to you.
Omni pairs an on-site third-party spa and formal lounges with late-night bars and live entertainment.
Choose Omni for nightlife variety and a full set of lounge/restaurant atmospheres in one property.
Hyatt House leans toward practical wellness and casual evening options.
Choose Hyatt House for quieter nights and practical wellness offerings rather than a nightlife scene.

Omni William Penn — steps from Mellon Square, Market Square, convention center and downtown attractions.

Hyatt House — suite layouts with kitchenettes, complimentary breakfast and practical amenities for longer visits.

Omni William Penn — tens of thousands of square feet of meeting space and multiple ballrooms, including a two-tier Grand Ballroom.

Hyatt House — simpler 3-star product with included breakfast and fewer frills, focused on neighborhood convenience.
Hyatt House has an indoor pool; Omni William Penn does not have an on-site pool.
Hyatt House is located in the Shadyside/Bloomfield area near Carnegie Mellon; the Omni is downtown and a short drive or T-ride away.
Omni William Penn has multiple distinct outlets (Terrace Room, Palm Court, Tap Room, Speakeasy, Mellon Square Coffee and a bagel shop); Hyatt House offers H Bar, a snack bar/deli and a bar/lounge.
Yes — both properties accept guests of all ages, though room renters must be at least 21; Hyatt House is not adults-only and neither is Omni.
Hyatt House includes a complimentary buffet breakfast; Omni William Penn does not include breakfast in standard room rates (buffet available for a fee).
Explore how Omni William Penn Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·